AI, Sameness and the Art of Differentiation: Why Scaleups Should Choose Creative Boldness Over Algorithmic Conformity for Growth

The Paradox of AI Differentiation in Scaleup Growth Strategy

We are living in extraordinary times, getting a front-row seat to a remarkable shift in the world, in which Artificial Intelligence (especially generative models) has moved from "Terminator 2 science fiction scare-mongering" to a standard operating model in businesses worldwide. Marketing teams, growth leaders, and founders now use AI for content, targeting, forecasting, and optimisation, among others. As a result, each week I hear about designers, agencies, and creatives being displaced by cheaper alternatives for developing brand and marketing strategies to support business growth.

But at what cost? Short-term, it might look great to the board: "we can cut costs here", "we can increase our output 10X". But what about the long-term brand and sustainable growth prospects? Does anyone care about that?

McKinsey’s latest survey shows that nearly nine in ten organisations use AI regularly in at least one function, and high performers are redesigning workflows to unlock its potential.

But beneath this AI excitement is a strategic tension:

The very technologies that promise productivity can also push organisations toward safer, more generic outputs. In practice, this means convergence, not differentiation.

Has everyone forgotten that AI is currently set on a level playing field? As a founder, CEO, investor, or board member seeking business growth, do you want strategies that create stand-out, differentiation, and individuality in your sector to propel you to number 1 and create market defensibility?

Yes, AI is phenomenally good at recombining patterns and phenomenal at basic efficiencies and roll outs of campaigns etc, but currently it is not inherently inventive and woefully bad at conceptual creative - because this requires divergent thinking and a right brain 'joining of the dots' - that wonderful flow state that super talented creatives and strategists can enter and produce category defining growth strategies and campaigns.

Without strategic direction, AI is merely accelerating what already exists, and when every brand uses the same prompts, templates, and optimisation loops, the result is a sea of sameness, dullness, and generic marketing (which we've all seen in our daily lives).

This matters because the value that separates enduring scaleups from ephemeral ones is not operational efficiency. It is distinctiveness.

Differentiation Is a Strategic Superpower

For decades, strategic brand research has shown that differentiation is a cornerstone of long-term financial and competitive advantage. In other words, brands that are meaningfully distinct in customers' minds outperform their peers in loyalty, pricing power, and market resilience.

Interestingly, emerging research from McKinsey on organisational creativity confirms an even deeper insight:

Companies that nurture creative thinking - especially at the leadership level - achieve higher growth and profitability than those that prioritise optimisation alone.

In an AI-powered world, the rarest resource becomes good old human original thinking. It is differentiation that becomes a strategic asset for scaleups, and it can change the game for you across 3 core areas:

1. Customer Growth: 

Distinctive brands attract attention in a crowded market and deepen emotional resonance.

2. Talent Magnetism: 

Creative organisations attract and retain higher-order talent, and access to the best people gives you the best chance of achieving your growth ambitions. Plus the brain power and divergent thinking of people who can solve unforeseen challenges as you navigate the choppy waters of growth.

3. Investor Confidence: 

Boards and investors increasingly value scaleups with defensible, recognisable brands, not just performance-led business models. A clear, differentiated brand narrative reduces risk, strengthens pricing power and signals long-term strategic coherence - all of which contribute to stronger valuations at IPO or exit.

The Risk of Same-Same AI Output

Generative AI is trained on large datasets and internalises common patterns. By default, it reflects what already exists, which is both its strength and its limitation.

Recent academic analyses suggest that while AI can accelerate human creativity, its outputs can reduce the diversity of ideas if not intentionally guided.

Average ideas drive average outcomes, and unsurprisingly, predictable ideas struggle to scale into cultural significance. Scaleups that prioritise AI-led optimisation without anchoring themselves in creative strategy first risk mediocrity.

Leadership, Culture and the Creative Courage to Embrace Bold Ideas

Culture flows from leadership. If bold ideas are consistently dismissed as “too risky” or “too creative”, organisations drift toward safety and sameness. Boards and CEOs must actively create space for experimentation, creative challenge and long-term brand thinking alongside performance metrics.

What should CEOs, boards and investors do next?

1. Start with narrative, not outputs

Define why your organisation matters and what your true market positioning is before automating content or campaigns.

2. Treat AI as an amplifier, not a replacement.

Use it to explore data insights that could inform possibilities, but rely on human judgment to generate conceptual ideas and choose direction.

3. Embed creative judgment in leadership workflows.

Encourage right-brain divergent thinking: areas in the business or times when people aren't on Slack, in back-to-back meetings, staring at dashboards, or doing 'A-type left brain work'.

4. Reward bold thinking with structured experimentation.

Discouraging “too risky” ideas too early kills differentiation. When agencies present ideas, don't judge them immediately; allow them to sit for a bit, and be open to new thinking, create a culture where people can have abstract thoughts.

5. Balance efficiency, differentiation and distinctiveness.

If you focus solely on short-term, data-driven performance marketing, you are missing out on brand marketing and are essentially constraining your growth.

Highly innovative marketing gets people talking about your brand.

In a world increasingly shaped by algorithmic predictability, AI differentiation in scaleup growth doesn’t emerge by accident. It needs active leadership, creative courage and a culture that allows original thinking to flourish.

While it is important to be different, it is more important to be distinct (recognised easily). Use distinctiveness to get noticed, and differentiation to give people a reason to care.

AI will change how we work, but it cannot change why we work. That purpose and the distinctiveness that flows from it will determine who wins the next decade of scale-up growth in the UK.

If your company struggles to think of an idea that feels too different, too daring, or too creative, that hesitation is itself a strategic signal.

If you’re a founder, CEO or board member grappling with growth strategy in an AI world and want strategic guidance on balancing efficiency with differentiation, connect with us at OSER. We help leadership teams define the right bet, not just the easy one.

Connect with OSER ->

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Founders, CEOs, and boards often ask us the following questions when considering AI, differentiation, and growth.

What does differentiation mean in an AI-driven market?

In an AI-driven market, differentiation is less about tools and more about judgement. AI can replicate patterns at scale, but it cannot define why a brand matters, what it stands for, or how it should show up differently in the world. Differentiation arises from strategic choices: narrative, positioning, and creative direction that AI then helps execute, not invent.

Is AI making brands and marketing more generic?

It can if used without a clear strategic direction. Generative AI is trained on existing data, so without human judgement it tends to reproduce what already works rather than create what is new. This often leads to a “sea of sameness,” in which content, campaigns, and messaging feel interchangeable across categories.

How can scaleups use AI without losing authenticity?

By defining authenticity before automation. Scaleups that retain authenticity use AI to accelerate expression, not to replace thinking. That means being clear on values, tone, positioning and long-term ambition and using AI to scale those ideas consistently, rather than asking AI to decide them.

Why is creative thinking still important for scale-up growth?

Because growth plateaus are rarely solved by optimisation alone. Creative thinking helps leadership teams see new category entry points, reframe customer value and imagine bolder futures. In an AI-enabled world, creativity becomes more valuable, not less - it is what separates leaders from followers.

Can AI help with differentiation rather than harm it?

Yes, when used as an amplifier. AI is powerful at exploring scenarios, stress-testing ideas and scaling execution. When paired with strong human creative direction, it can accelerate differentiation rather than flatten it. The risk arises when AI replaces creative leadership instead of supporting it.

What role do CEOs and boards play in protecting differentiation?

A decisive one. Culture flows from leadership. If bold ideas are consistently dismissed as “too risky” or “too creative”, organisations drift toward safety and sameness. Boards and CEOs must actively create space for experimentation and divergent thinking. creative challenge and long-term brand thinking alongside performance metrics.

How does differentiation impact talent attraction and retention?

Distinctive companies attract people who want to build something meaningful, not just efficient. Strong positioning and creative ambition signal confidence, purpose and momentum - all of which matter to senior talent choosing where to invest their energy and careers.

Why does differentiation matter for IPO or exit value?

Because investors value resilience and future growth, not just current performance. A clear, differentiated brand narrative reduces risk, strengthens pricing power and signals long-term strategic coherence - all of which contribute to stronger valuations at IPO or exit.

What is the biggest risk for scaleups relying too heavily on AI?

The greatest risk is strategic convergence: becoming indistinguishable from competitors while believing that efficiency equates to advantage. Scaleups that outsource too much thinking to AI risk optimising themselves into mediocrity.

How does OSER help leadership teams navigate this?

OSER works with founders, CEOs, and boards to clarify strategic direction, positioning, and creative ambition, ensuring that AI is used as a growth enabler rather than a shortcut. We help leadership teams make confident, differentiated choices that support long-term growth, talent attraction and investor confidence.